When profitable energy investments have to wait

CONFERENCE | Improving energy efficiency is often profitable, but it still has to compete with roof replacements, waste room refurbishments and new property management systems. For smaller property owners, limited time and resources can make it difficult to take on another project.

Rikard Silverfur, Head of Development and Sustainability at the Swedish Property Federation, highlights this challenge. Its members range from large property companies with extensive portfolios to small family businesses that own just a few properties. These differences become particularly apparent when energy efficiency plans need to be put into practice.

“It is about making the financial case and securing financing. Owners need to obtain quotes and speak to their commercial or residential tenants. In a tenant-owner association, the matter also needs to go through the annual general meeting,” says Rikard Silverfur.

Larger property companies often handle this as part of their operations, sometimes with support from dedicated sustainability, project or property management teams. Even then, an energy efficiency project may have to give way to an investment expected to deliver a higher return.

“They might pursue that opportunity instead. But energy efficiency will always be a profitable and competitive investment,” says Rikard Silverfur.

When long-term goals meet short-term priorities

An investment is also assessed according to how long the owner intends to keep the building. Silverfur distinguishes between owners focused on long-term property management and those whose business centres on buying and selling properties. These perspectives often come into conflict when investment decisions are made.

“This conflict is nothing new, and it applies to all investments. It might be about replacing a kitchen worktop with marble to increase an apartment’s selling price, or improving net operating income, which is better in the long term,” he says.

In the commercial property market, the length of the lease can also affect the financial case. Ideally, an investment that improves a building’s energy performance should pay for itself within the remaining lease term.

“A long-term improvement benefits more than the current tenant. It is an investment in the future. The challenge is to agree on how the investment and savings should be shared. Unfortunately, there is no standard solution.”

One party pays, the other saves

The time horizon does not always resolve the question of who pays for an investment and who benefits from it. A commercial tenant whose energy costs are excluded from the rent pays their own energy bills. If the property owner funds measures that reduce energy use, the direct savings therefore go to the tenant. Silverfur believes both parties need to consider the total cost.

“What matters is the tenant’s total cost, including both rent and energy. If one can be reduced, there may be room to discuss adjusting the other.”

If an agreement can be reached, the investment may become more attractive to the property owner, as an adjusted rent can increase net operating income and, ultimately, the property’s value.

The parties’ interests can also diverge in other ways. A property owner may want to invest in a building to improve its energy performance and financing terms, while the tenant may be unwilling to contribute to the cost. Silverfur describes the frustration that arises when the parties cannot find a solution.

The sector currently lacks a standard model for this. In the commercial property market, owners and tenants need to reach agreements on a case-by-case basis. In the residential sector, however, the Swedish Property Federation, Public Housing Sweden and the Swedish Union of Tenants can develop joint agreements to support negotiations. Even so, energy efficiency improvements have traditionally not been considered to affect a home’s utility value, a key basis for setting residential rents in Sweden. This makes it difficult to finance measures aimed solely at improving energy efficiency.

“Ultimately, it always comes down to local rent negotiations,” says Rikard Silverfur.

Collaboration as the basis for energy efficiency

The lack of a standard model for sharing costs and savings is an obstacle property owners need to overcome before planning their next steps. An energy audit is one way to move forward.

“An energy audit provides a more detailed analysis than an energy performance certificate. It shows the building’s current position, its potential for improvement and when measures can be carried out. Those who achieve the best results set clear goals. If the potential is unclear, an energy expert can help,” says Rikard Silverfur.

Securing financing requires thorough documentation and a clear dialogue between the property owner and the lender, particularly if the property already has poor energy performance. Silverfur highlights sustainability-linked loans as one way to assess a planned transition.

“The property owner needs to show the building’s current energy performance, the planned measures, what they will cost and the energy performance they could deliver. Bringing that complete picture to the discussion with the lender improves the chances of finding a solution.”

Despite the challenges, Silverfur believes progress is being made. At Clima Energy Nordic, he hopes to see concrete examples of how the property and energy sectors can develop their collaboration.

“There is a lot to gain from highlighting partnerships that benefit both parties. A municipality might, for example, have worked with flexibility markets, using a building’s thermal inertia to lower the temperature by a degree or so without compromising indoor comfort. It makes a big difference to district heating producers if properties reduce their heating demand at those particular times. I would also like to discuss how the process for sustainability-linked loans can become faster and simpler,” says Rikard Silverfur.


How can investments move forward when costs, benefits and responsibilities fall to different parties? Join the discussion with Rikard Silverfur, Johan Almesjö and Sofia Cederlöf on 3 February, 14:15–15:00, at Clima Energy Nordic in Gothenburg. Read more about the conference »